What this lesson teaches
I can judge how much leaders, the army and other groups did to set up authoritarian rule.
Syllabus K330, Rise of Authoritarian Regimes, Learning Outcomes. Evaluate the roles of key players in the establishment of authoritarian rule.
Make a guess
In September 1931 Japanese army officers in Manchuria staged a railway explosion and blamed China. What do you think happened next?
- The cabinet punished the officers and pulled the army back.
- China and Japan settled the dispute peacefully through the League of Nations.
- The army seized Manchuria, and the cabinet could not stop it.
Show the answer
The army seized Manchuria, and the cabinet could not stop it.
The Kwantung Army acted without government approval. Its success boosted military prestige and created the puppet state Manchukuo.
Past wins and the 1931 seizure of Manchuria made the army look strong and showed the cabinet could not stop it.
Japan beat China in 1894 to 1895 and Russia in 1904 to 1905. These wins raised the military's prestige, the respect and influence it enjoyed. Japan also built an empire, ruling Taiwan and Korea as colonies. Many Japanese also felt that Western powers treated Japan as less than equal. Ultranationalists used past wins, fear of foreign threats and this anger. They argued that military leadership would keep Japan strong. Their claims that Japan was superior were excuses for expansion. They were not evidence that neighbouring peoples wanted Japanese rule.
Manchuria is a region in north-east China. The Kwantung Army was a Japanese force based there. In September 1931, some of its officers set off a blast on a Japanese-run railway near Mukden. They blamed China and used it as an excuse to attack. The cabinet wanted to limit the fighting but failed to stop the army. In 1932, Japan created Manchukuo, a puppet state. It looked independent, but Japan controlled it.
Military supporters praised the gains as successes that cautious politicians had failed to deliver. The government accepted what the army had done. So officers learned that disobeying could bring success, not punishment. Manchuria mattered in two ways. It boosted the military's reputation, and it showed the cabinet could not control the army. Neither public support nor land gained made the invasion right.
- 1894-1895, 1904-1905
- Japan defeats China, then Russia.
- Mukden, September 1931
- Kwantung Army fakes an excuse to seize Manchuria.
- Manchukuo, 1932
- Puppet state controlled by Japan.
Real examples to use
Racial equality proposal, 1919
At the Paris peace talks, Japan asked for racial equality to be written into the League's rules. On 11 April 1919, 11 of 17 delegates voted for it, but Wilson ruled that it needed every vote.
US Immigration Act, 1924
A US law of 24 May 1924 barred immigrants who could not become citizens. In practice it shut out the Japanese, and it set off protests in Japan.
Worked example: The cabinet pays for a move it did not order, 1931
On 19 September 1931, the day after the Mukden blast, the cabinet decided not to widen the fighting.
- Soon after, Japan's army in Korea sent troops across the border into Manchuria without orders from Tokyo.
- The cabinet did not punish this. It agreed to pay for the move, which approved it after the fact.
- Officers learned that disobeying could pay, and the cabinet looked too weak to stop them.
Watch out for this
Manchukuo was an independent country.
Manchukuo looked independent, but Japan controlled it. It was a puppet state.
Check your understanding
What did the Manchurian Incident show about Japan's government?
- The cabinet could not stop the army acting on its own.
- The cabinet had ordered the army to invade so it could win the next election.
- Manchuria's people voted to become independent from China under Japanese protection.
Show the answer
The cabinet could not stop the army acting on its own.
Yes. It exposed the weakness of civilian control.
Check your understanding
Japan had beaten China in 1895 and Russia in 1905. Why did these wins still matter in the 1930s?
- They proved that neighbouring peoples wanted to live under Japanese rule.
- They had given Japan all the land it needed, so expansion had stopped.
- They gave the military prestige, so its claim to keep Japan strong sounded believable.
Show the answer
They gave the military prestige, so its claim to keep Japan strong sounded believable.
Yes. Ultranationalists used past wins to argue that military leaders should guide Japan.