An adviser with real power

G3 Full History - syllabus K330, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can weigh up how far officials, rulers, chiefs and traders helped European powers extend their control.

    Syllabus K330, Extension of European Control in Southeast Asia, Learning Outcomes. Assess the roles of individuals and groups in the extension of European influence.

Make a guess

Under the Pangkor Treaty, the Sultan had to follow the British Resident's advice. On what do you think he could still decide for himself?

  1. Land and justice, because a Resident could just make suggestions.
  2. Taxes and spending, because he was still the ruler.
  3. Only Malay religion and custom.
Show the answer

Only Malay religion and custom.

Everything else, including revenue, followed the Resident's advice, so the Sultan kept his title but lost real power.

The Sultan kept his title, but he had to follow the British Resident's advice on almost everything except religion and custom.

Under the Pangkor Treaty, the Sultan had to ask for and follow the Resident's advice. The only exceptions were Malay religion and custom. This covered revenue, the government's income from taxes. Whoever controls taxes controls much of government. So the Sultan kept his title but lost real power.

This was indirect rule. British officers ruled through the existing rulers. It could still be forceful. The first Resident of Perak, J. W. W. Birch, challenged the chiefs' power and their taxes. This angered them. Birch was killed in 1875, and British troops were sent in.

A state could be independent in name while outsiders made its key decisions. That is different from annexation, where a power openly takes over the land.

Resident
British official whose advice the Sultan had to follow.
Exceptions
Malay religion and custom.
J. W. W. Birch
First Resident of Perak, killed in 1875.

Real examples to use

Article VI of the treaty, 1874

The Resident's advice 'must be asked and acted upon' on every question except those 'touching Malay religion and custom'.

Pasir Salak, 2 November 1875

Birch was killed at Pasir Salak. British troops crushed the resistance; the chief Maharaja Lela was hanged in 1877, and Sultan Abdullah was exiled to the Seychelles.

Hugh Low, Resident 1877 to 1889

Low moved his base to Kuala Kangsar to stay close to the Malay chiefs, and worked through them instead of against them.

Worked example: Perak, 1874 to 1875

Sultan Abdullah keeps his title, but the Resident, Birch, tries to take over the collection of taxes.

  1. The Sultan still holds his title and handles religion and custom.
  2. But he cannot refuse advice on raising and spending taxes.
  3. So judge power by who makes decisions, not by who holds the title.

Watch out for this

A Resident could only suggest things, so the Sultan stayed fully independent.

The Sultan had to follow the Resident's advice, so real power moved to Britain.

Check your understanding

In which areas did the Sultan NOT have to follow the Resident's advice?

  1. Taxes, revenue and land.
  2. Defence and foreign relations, since a Resident just gave suggestions.
  3. Malay religion and custom.
Show the answer

Malay religion and custom.

Yes. On almost everything else, including taxes, he had to follow advice.

Check your understanding

The Sultan of Perak kept his title after 1874. Why do historians still say real power moved to Britain?

  1. British troops ruled Perak directly as a colony from 1874.
  2. He had to follow the Resident's advice on revenue, which paid for government.
  3. The Sultan handed his title to the Resident soon after the treaty.
Show the answer

He had to follow the Resident's advice on revenue, which paid for government.

Yes. Whoever controls taxes controls much of government.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • Hansard, Commons debate on Perak, 26 May 1876

    Ernest Noel MP, House of Commons debate on Perak, 26 May 1876. Concise paraphrase of his argument.

  • Hansard, Commons debate on Perak, 26 May 1876

    James Lowther, parliamentary under-secretary for the colonies, replying in the same Commons debate, 26 May 1876. Concise paraphrase.

  • Control over taxation

    Sir Charles W. Dilke MP, asking the colonial secretary a question in the House of Commons, 7 June 1878; paraphrase.

  • The colonial secretary replies

    Sir Michael Hicks-Beach, secretary of state for the colonies, replying to Dilke in the same Commons sitting, 7 June 1878; paraphrase.

  • Hansard, Commons debate on Perak, 26 May 1876

    An original cartoon drawn for these notes in the style of a British satirical magazine cartoon of 1876, when Parliament was debating the war in Perak that followed the killing of the first Resident, J. W. W. Birch, in November 1875. It is not a copy of a real cartoon.

  • Hansard, Commons debate on Perak, 26 May 1876

    Extract from the speech of Ernest Noel MP opening the House of Commons debate on the murder of J. W. W. Birch and British intervention in the Malay Peninsula, 26 May 1876. Hansard, House of Commons, vol. 229. Parliamentary copyright, reproduced under the Open Parliament Licence.

  • Hansard, Commons debate on Perak, 26 May 1876

    Extract from the speech of Sir George Campbell MP, a former senior official in India, in the same House of Commons debate, 26 May 1876. Hansard, House of Commons, vol. 229. Parliamentary copyright, reproduced under the Open Parliament Licence.

  • Hansard, Commons debate on Perak, 26 May 1876

    Extract from the reply of James Lowther, Under-Secretary of State for the Colonies, in the same debate, 26 May 1876. Hansard, House of Commons, vol. 229. Parliamentary copyright, reproduced under the Open Parliament Licence.

  • the Colonial Secretary answers a question, 1878

    Extract from the answer of Sir Michael Hicks-Beach, Secretary of State for the Colonies, to a question from Sir Charles Dilke MP asking how Perak now differed from an annexed province, House of Commons, 7 June 1878. Hansard, House of Commons, vol. 240. Parliamentary copyright, reproduced under the Open Parliament Licence.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready