What this lesson teaches
I can weigh up how the peace treaties after World War I changed Europe, especially Germany.
Syllabus K336, After World War I, Learning Outcomes. Assess the impact of post-war peace settlements on Europe.
Make a guess
At the 1919 peace talks, France had been invaded by Germany twice in fifty years. What do you think its leader most wanted?
- A League of Nations to replace national armies.
- Security, so that Germany could never attack France again.
- A quick deal so trade with Germany could restart.
Show the answer
Security, so that Germany could never attack France again.
Clemenceau wanted Germany's army limited and its troops kept away from France, as well as payment for damage.
France wanted security from Germany, Britain wanted payment and a stable Europe, and the USA's Wilson wanted a League to keep peace.
Georges Clemenceau led France. German armies had invaded France in 1870 and again in 1914. So he wanted protection from another attack. He also wanted Germany to pay for the damage in France. A small German army, kept away from France's border, would make an invasion harder. So his aim was security as well as punishment.
David Lloyd George was Britain's prime minister. Many British voters wanted Germany to pay. But he also wanted Germany to recover, so it could trade with Britain again. Britain wanted a balance of power, where no one country could control Europe. A bitter or unstable Germany could itself threaten peace.
Woodrow Wilson was the US president. He wanted a League of Nations, where countries would settle disputes by talking. His Fourteen Points, his 1918 plan for peace, also called for fewer weapons. They asked for borders that followed what peoples wanted.
These ideals clashed with the winners' demands for security and land. Italy also took part in the main talks. Germany was not allowed to negotiate; it was handed the terms. So the treaty was a compromise, and no leader got everything.
- Clemenceau (France)
- Security from Germany and payment for damage.
- Lloyd George (Britain)
- Make Germany pay, but let it recover to trade.
- Wilson (USA)
- A League of Nations and the Fourteen Points.
Worked example: Why limit an army?
France had been invaded and wanted less risk of another German attack.
- Aim: security against another invasion.
- Term: a small German army and no troops in the Rhineland.
- Trade-off: this made Germans resentful, which could weaken the peace.
Watch out for this
Clemenceau only wanted revenge, and Wilson wanted no punishment at all.
Clemenceau mainly wanted security. Wilson accepted some terms against Germany but focused on the League.
Check your understanding
What did Lloyd George want from the peace?
- A peace with no League of Nations, so that Britain kept a free hand.
- Germany to pay, but also recover enough to trade with Britain.
- Germany broken up into small states so it could not threaten France again.
Show the answer
Germany to pay, but also recover enough to trade with Britain.
Yes. He balanced public anger with Britain's trade interests.
Check your understanding
Why could Clemenceau's and Lloyd George's aims clash?
- Britain wanted Germany to pay nothing, but France wanted heavy payments.
- Both wanted to rule Germany, but disagreed on how to share it.
- France wanted Germany weak, but Britain wanted it able to trade.
Show the answer
France wanted Germany weak, but Britain wanted it able to trade.
Yes. A Germany kept too weak, or left bitter, could not trade with Britain or help keep Europe stable.