Consequences of restricting trade

G3 Economics - syllabus K343, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain how trade restrictions affect the home country and its trading partners.

    Syllabus K343, 6.2.6. Consequences of trade restrictions: impact of trade restrictions on the home country and its trading partners; advantages and disadvantages of restricting free trade

Make a guess

A country puts a tariff on imported steel. Who in that country loses?

  1. Firms that use steel, and their customers.
  2. Foreign steel makers, who now sell less steel in that country.
  3. No one, because local steel makers gain more sales.
Show the answer

Firms that use steel, and their customers.

Car makers and builders pay more for steel, so their costs rise. They may raise prices or cut jobs.

Protection can save some jobs at home, but raises prices, reduces choice and may provoke retaliation.

For the home country, protection can save jobs in protected industries and help infant industries grow. It can raise tariff revenue and reduce a current account deficit.

But consumers pay higher prices and have less choice. Firms that use imported materials face higher costs, so they become less competitive. Protected firms may become inefficient, because they face less competition.

For trading partners, protection cuts their exports, so their output and jobs fall. They may retaliate, or hit back, with their own tariffs. A trade war can then reduce trade for everyone, hurting exporters in both countries.

Overall, restricting free trade helps some groups and harms others. Most economists argue that widespread protection makes countries poorer. But targeted, short-term protection can be justified.

Protection: home-country gains
Protected jobs, infant industry growth, tariff revenue.
Protection: home-country costs
Higher prices, less choice, dearer inputs, inefficiency.
Protection: effect on trading partners
Lower exports; possible retaliation and trade war.

Worked example: US steel tariffs, 2018

In March 2018, the United States put a 25% tariff on imported steel.

  1. US steel makers: imports became dearer, so they could sell more steel at home.
  2. US firms that use steel, such as car makers: their costs rose.
  3. Trading partners: Canada, Mexico and the EU hit back with tariffs on US goods, from pork and orange juice to bourbon whiskey and motorcycles.
  4. US exporters of those goods then lost sales abroad.

Watch out for this

Asked whether protection helps an economy: "A tariff is a tax on imports, and a quota limits how many can enter."

That only describes the methods. Explain their effects: who gains, such as protected firms and their workers, and who loses, such as consumers and exporters.

Check your understanding

What is a likely consequence of a tariff for the trading partner?

  1. Its exports rise, because it sells more to other markets instead.
  2. Its exports fall, and it may retaliate with its own tariffs.
  3. It is unaffected, because the tariff is paid by buyers in the other country.
Show the answer

Its exports fall, and it may retaliate with its own tariffs.

Right. Lower demand for its goods can lead to a trade war.

Check your understanding

Tariffs shield local steel makers from foreign rivals for many years. What is the most likely long-run result?

  1. Firms that use steel gain as their input costs fall
  2. The protected firms become the lowest-cost steel producers in the world
  3. Steel prices at home fall as local output keeps rising
  4. Protected firms face less pressure to cut costs and improve
Show the answer

Protected firms face less pressure to cut costs and improve

Right. With less competition, protected firms may become inefficient.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready