What this lesson teaches
I can explain how a person's identities overlap and change, and how they make a society diverse.
Syllabus K230, Issue 2, Guiding Question 1. Factors that shape the identities of people and contribute to a diverse society
Make a guess
Two Singaporean classmates are both of Indian heritage. Do you think they must share the same religion?
- Yes, because ethnic heritage decides which religion you follow.
- No: Indian residents include Hindus, Muslims, Christians and other faiths.
- Yes, unless one of them has a parent from a different heritage group.
Show the answer
No: Indian residents include Hindus, Muslims, Christians and other faiths.
Census 2020 found 57.3% of Indian residents were Hindu, 23.4% Muslim and 12.6% Christian. One identity does not decide another.
Identity is how you see yourself and the groups you belong to. Everyone has several identities at once.
Four factors shape identity in this chapter. They are race and ethnicity, religion, socio-economic status and nationality. Socio-economic status is a person's social and economic position. Nationality is a legal link to a country, usually through citizenship. These factors can shape what people go through, the groups they join and what they think matters.
Identity also includes roles and interests, such as being a sister, a student or a musician.
These parts overlap. Two people can share a nationality and ethnic heritage but have different religions, family incomes or goals. Sharing one part of identity does not mean sharing every part. Belonging to one group does not stop you belonging to another.
A diverse society has people with different backgrounds, beliefs and ways of life. There is diversity within groups, not just between them. So in an answer, explain the link the evidence shows. Do not treat one label as a full picture of a person.
Issue 2 asks how people with different identities can live in harmony. Harmony means people of different races, religions and backgrounds living and working together in peace. It needs trust and respect. It is more than just having no conflict.
- Identity
- How you see yourself and the groups you belong to.
- Four factors
- Race and ethnicity, religion, socio-economic status, nationality.
- Diversity and harmony
- Diversity is difference between and within groups; harmony is living together across it with trust and respect.
Real examples to use
Census 2020, religion by ethnic group
Among Indian residents, 57.3% were Hindu, 23.4% Muslim and 12.6% Christian. Among Chinese residents, 40.4% were Buddhist and 26% had no religion. Use it to show diversity within one ethnic group.
Worked example: Religion within ethnic groups, Census 2020
Singapore's Census of Population 2020 asked residents about their ethnic group and their religion. Among Indian residents, 57.3% were Hindu, 23.4% Muslim and 12.6% Christian. Among Chinese residents, 40.4% were Buddhist and about 26% had no religion.
- People who share an ethnic group can differ in religion, so one identity does not decide another.
- So in an answer, do not assume a person's religion from their ethnic group. Use what the evidence shows.
- Limit: census figures describe groups, not individuals. They show how common each religion is, not how much it matters to each person.
Watch out for this
People who share one identity must think and act the same.
People share some identities and differ in others, so members of any group can think and act differently. Explain a view from the person's own reasons, not from a label.
Check your understanding
What does it mean to say a person has overlapping identities?
- They belong to several groups at once, such as a faith, a nation and a CCA club.
- They switch between identities, so they hold one identity at a time in each setting.
- Their groups share the same members, such as classmates who also attend one church.
Show the answer
They belong to several groups at once, such as a faith, a nation and a CCA club.
Right. Identities combine; one does not replace another.
Check your understanding
Which situation best shows harmony, in the sense that Issue 2 uses?
- Neighbours of different religions keep apart, so they rarely argue.
- Neighbours of different religions help one another and trust each other.
- Neighbours share one religion, so they have few differences to manage.
Show the answer
Neighbours of different religions help one another and trust each other.
Right. Harmony means living and working together across differences, with trust and respect.