What this lesson teaches
I can explain why the Korean War and the Vietnam War broke out, and what followed each war.
Syllabus K230, The Cold War, Learning Outcomes. Explain the reasons for the outbreak of the Vietnam War, and its aftermath.
Make a guess
South Vietnam's leader Diem relied on US aid and silenced his opponents. How do you think many South Vietnamese saw his government?
- They backed it strongly, because it was firmly anti-communist and US-backed.
- They saw it as a puppet of the North.
- They lost trust in it, because of harsh rule and favouritism.
Show the answer
They lost trust in it, because of harsh rule and favouritism.
A government needs people to accept its right to rule. Diem's methods turned many against him, including Buddhists.
The North tightened communist control, while Diem's harsh and unfair rule in the South turned many people against him.
In the North, Ho Chi Minh and the party leaders tightened their control. Land was taken from landlords and given to poorer farmers. But the campaign was violent, and opponents were punished. Stronger control did not mean everyone supported the government. The North rebuilt its economy, strengthened its army and kept its aim of reunifying Vietnam.
In the South, Diem relied on US aid and silenced political opponents. He gave top jobs to his family and to fellow Catholics. Yet most South Vietnamese were Buddhists. A government needs legitimacy. This means people accept its right to rule and are willing to cooperate. Harsh rule and favouritism lost Diem that trust.
The strategic hamlet programme moved villagers into fenced, guarded settlements. The aim was to cut them off from armed rebels. Some families were forced from their homes and fields. So a policy meant to improve security could create anger.
In 1963, the Buddhist crisis showed another source of opposition. Buddhists protested against discrimination, and Diem's crackdown made them angrier. Criticising Diem did not make every Buddhist or unhappy farmer a communist. In November 1963, South Vietnamese generals overthrew and killed Diem in a coup, a seizure of power. Removing him did not bring a stable government or solve the wider problems.
- Land reform
- North takes land from landlords, often violently.
- Strategic hamlets
- Fenced villages to separate farmers from rebels.
- November 1963
- Diem overthrown and killed by his generals.
Real examples to use
Thich Quang Duc, 11 June 1963
A Buddhist monk burned himself to death in a Saigon street to protest against Diem's treatment of Buddhists. Photographs of it went round the world.
Coup, November 1963
South Vietnamese generals overthrew Diem and killed him on 2 November 1963. A string of short-lived military governments followed.
Worked example: Operation Sunrise, 1962
In March 1962, the first big strategic hamlet operation began in Binh Duong province, north of Saigon. A US general later reported that people there were herded into the hamlets against their will.
- Aim: cut villagers off from the Viet Cong, who relied on them for food and recruits.
- Method: many families were moved by force, and some saw their old homes burned.
- Result: a policy meant to protect villagers turned many of them against Diem's government.
Watch out for this
Every opponent of Diem was a communist taking orders from the North.
Many opponents, such as Buddhist protesters, simply objected to Diem's harsh and unfair rule.
Check your understanding
Why did many South Vietnamese turn against Diem?
- He held free elections in 1956 that the communists won.
- His harsh rule, favouritism and forced moves lost their trust.
- He gave land to poor farmers, which angered the landlords and the USA.
Show the answer
His harsh rule, favouritism and forced moves lost their trust.
Yes. Without trust, his government struggled for support.
Check your understanding
Generals overthrew Diem in November 1963. Why did this not solve the South's problems?
- The USA pulled out its advisers in protest at the coup.
- The North's army captured Saigon straight after the coup.
- Short-lived military governments followed, and they struggled to win trust too.
Show the answer
Short-lived military governments followed, and they struggled to win trust too.
Yes. Removing one leader did not give the South a stable, trusted government.